>> [gavel] >> good afternoon and welcome to the san francisco board of supervisors for today, tuesday february 13, 2024. clerk could you please call the roll. >> thank you mr. president. supervisor chan. >> present. >> supervisor dorsey. >> present. >> supervisor engardio. >> present. >> supervisor mandelman. >> present. >> supervisor melgar. >> present. >> supervisor peskin. >> present. >> supervisor preston. >> present. >> supervisor ronen. >> present. >> supervisor safai. >> present.

>> supervisor stefani. >> present >> and supervisor walton. >> present. mr. president all members are present. >> thank you madam clerk. the san francisco board of supervisors noles that we're on the enseeded ancestral land of the ramaytush ohlone who are the original inhabits of the san francisco peninsula. as the stewards with the land and the ramaytush ohlone never seeded lost nor forgotten the responsibilities of this place and people people. as guests we recognize that we benefit from living and working on their traditional homeland. we may our respects by representing the ramaytush ohlone community and by affirming their sovereign rights as first peoples. colleagues please join me in the pledge of allegiance. >> i pledge allegiance to the flag to the united states of america and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and

justice for all. >> madam clerk do we have any communications? >> yes mr. president of the san francisco board of supervisors welcomes all interested persons to attend this meeting in the chamber in city all second floor, room 250 where you may wife the proking on sfgtv at channel 26 or see the live stream online. to submit your public comment in writing send to the email address on the screen or use the u.s. postal service and send to the san francisco board of supervisors. 1 dr. b goodlett place. city hall. room 244, san francisco, 94102. to make a reasonable accommodation requests under the americans with

disabilities act the ada or to request language assistance please contact the clerk's office at least two business days in advance by calling the number on the screen. thank you mr. president. >> thank you madam clerk. is there a motion to approve the january 9, 2024 minutes? motion made by cat cat. second by supervisor mandelman. on that motion made and seconded. a roll call please. >> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor engardio. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye >> and supervisor ronen. >> aye. there are 11 ayes. >> that motion is

approved. [gavel] >> madam clerk would you please call the consent agenda. >> items one and two are consent. they're routine and if a member objects maybe considered separately. >> seeing no names on the roster we will take those same house, same call. shall this ordinance be finally passed. [gavel] >> next item please. >> item three is an ordinance to prohibit the rec and park department and planning department to clean up and reconstruct the marina yacht harbor by extend it by 150 feet of the current boundaries. >> we need a motion to excuse supervisor stefani as stated last week. motion and second. we will take that motion without objection. [gavel] >> supervisor stefani so on accused and on the item a roll call please.

>> supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor engardio. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye and supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> there are 10 ayes. >> shall this ordinance be finally passed and supervisor stefani may return. madam clerk next item please. >> item four this is an ordinance to retroactive three authorize the governor's office of business and economic development for the economic development and immigration integration efforts and amend the salary ordinance ordinance for 2023-24

and 2024-25 for the administrative position through february 28, 2025. >> roll call -- oh supervisor safai. >> [inaudible] to this item and also item 5 as well. >> will do. thank you. >> roll call. >> on item 4. supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor engardio. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> and supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> there are 11 ayes. >> the ordinance is passed on first reading. next item please. >> this is an ordinance to waive the

public works municipal code section 101.1 one for temporary street space occupancy permit fee in chinatown for saturday january saturday january 27, 2024 and saturday february 10, 2024 and for the sale of items in the holiday season and determine this. >> the ordinance is passed on first reading. item 6. >> is this is for the real property lease and clinic use 755 and 759 south van ness avenue and the adjacent parking lot for a monthly base rate of 52,000 and overall total annual base rent of 645,000 and 3% cpi

increases and one five year extension. >> same house, same call. the resolution adopted. next item please. >> number seven of the multi-family housing revenue notes for follow 67.6 million dollars and the conclusion of 151 unit multifamily rental housing project known as transbay block two west located at 200 folsom street. >> same house, same call. the resolution adopted. next item. >> item 8 resolution to thursday the department of the environment to enter into a grant agreement with dpr the california department of pesticide regulation to include dpr's standard resolution process. the term of this agreement is through december 31, 2025 or when the final deliverable is received which is earlier and not to

exceed as cited. >> same house, same call. resolution is aa do noted. next item please. >> item 9 resolution to approve with the internal revenue code section issuance of tax-exempt or obligation and sale by the california municipal financing authority of its revenue bonds for the benefit of the ignatian corporation in an aggregate principle amount of $150 million for cost of renovations and construction of school facility other matters defined in the item. . >> same house, same call the resolution is adopted. >> madam clerk can you read 10 through 16 together. >> for item 10 the fisherman's wharf community benefit district and 11 union square business

business and 12 tourism improvement district moscone expansion district for 13 downtown community benefit district for item 14 this is the soma west community benefit district and item 16 for the ocean avenue community benefit district for the community benefit district. >> seeing no names on the roster we will same house, same call. these resolutions are adopted. next item please. >> item 17 resolution to retroactively authorize the sfpd to enter into a memorandum of understanding agreement with the united states capital police to provide supplemental law enforcement services from january 1, 2021 through december 31, 2023. >> same house, same call. the resolution is adopted. [gavel] >> next item please. >> item 18 ordinance to amend the planning code to conditionally waive projects for projects along the downtown rail extension fee waiver to ooh! firm the ceqa determination and make the appropriate findings.

>> roll call. >> on item 18, supervisor safai. >> [off mic]. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> you aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor engardio. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye >> and supervisor ronen. >> aye. there are 11 ayes >> ordinance is passed on first reading and we will go to our 2:00 p.m. special order. madam clerk. >> the item at 2:00 p.m. is the appearance at the meeting by the honorable london breed to engage in a formal policy discussion with eligible board members. prior to the discussion

the mayor may address the board up to five minutes. >> thank you madam clerk. as there are no questions from the three eligible district supervisors. welcome madam mayor the floor is yours. >> thank you. thank you. all right. good afternoon and thank you members of the board of supervisors and the public and president peskin. one year ago we released a revitalized downtown plan. it was i culmination of practical steps as we needed to take big and bold transformative changes to our downtown area because that's what it's going to take for us to break free what downtown has been for decades, nine to five financial district, closed on weekend and the evening times. our plan is about creating a vision to imagine what downtown can be and delivering the building blocks to get there. the good news is we are finally

seeing improvements. in one study released last week san francisco saw one of the largest increases in people returning to downtown last year, a 23% increase from 2022-23. but we know that this increase is only a start. we have more work to do. today we released a one year update on what we have done since releasing the our road map to the future of san francisco. we focused on our work across nine core strategies including converting empty offices to other uses, making our neighborhoods clean, safe and welcoming, and recruiting new businesses while keeping our existing businesses stable. a lot of the this work has happened here in these chambers and we should all be very proud of that. together we passed laws to remove barriers to converting empty offices to

housing. we made it easier to fill vacant retail spaces. we reduced fees sorted with new housing. we changed our planning code to help small businesses open and operate. we reduced taxes for existing businesses and offered tax incentives for new businesses. and that's just the legislative work that has been happening. in addition to this our office of economic and workforce office of economic and workforce development has been working with community stakeholders to deliver key activations like our vacant to vibrant program to fill empty store fronts and it's a big hit. our street festivals and entertainment and bringing night life and excitement to the downtown and those events have been packed. and street improvements to make the neighborhood more inviting. we brought back the 1x which is a key for downtown workers, but we also need people to

invest here. and the good news is sha vo a $1 billion investment at in the transamerica pyramid buildings is renying one of the great -- is renewing one of our great icons downtown to make it more of an attractive destination. we are the ai capital of the world and growing leader in venture capital, public safety is improving. tourism is rebounding and new businesses continue to open in our city every single day. we're also continuing to think big and collaborating with the university of california and our historically black college and universities to get new campuses downtown. bringing students to downtown and closer to world changing ideas being born right in this city will create a stronger future. it will make san francisco an even

brighter beacon for those looking to change the world whether coming to the city from across the country or the world or whether they're right here in various neighborhoods in our city. that's how we're going to help our stagery and thrive. so what's next for us? the biggest issues besides continuing this progress is focusing on our tax reform needs. the treasurer controller and city economists released their report on what the landscape for tax reforms look like. it's been very predictable there is a lot of grumbling from those that like things the way they are but we need change and can't operate like it's 2019. we had a line out the door for prop m allocation of square footage before the pandemic where there was a wait list to develop new office spaces in this city. that line no longer exists, and what that means is we can't continue to do

business as usual. we have to make bold decisions. we have to incentivize and we have to do everything we can to not only attract new businesses but to retain the ones we have now. so i hope we can continue to work together to invest in our downtown to make significant changes, and remember that we got a lot of work to do to bring back tourism, conventions andnesses all over the city and county of san francisco and i hope that is top of mind for each and every one of you as we move forward this year. thank you all so much. >> thank you mayor breed and we look forward to seeing you next month and i know that supervisor mandelman and i look forward to working with and you your steam on the tax reform package that hopefully will come to this board later this year and with that question time is over for today. thank you mayor breed. madam clerk could you please read item number 19. >> item 19 this.

this does a res to add the veterans alley in o block of shannon street for the san francisco veterans mural project also known as veterans alley clothes urlocated in the tenderloin. >> roll call. >> on item 19 supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor engardio. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye >> and supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> there are 11 ayes. >> the resolution is adopted. [gavel] >> next item please. >> item 20. this is

a motion to appoint dimitri thierry cornet term ending january 6, 2026 and miriam zouzounis and golf cart terms ending january 6, 2028 to the small business commission. >> seeing no names on roster we will take same house, same call and the motion is approved. madam clerk can we please go to our committee report. >> yes. our committee report. item 33 was considered by the rules committee at a regular meeting on february 12. it was forwarded as a committee report and ordto amend the city administrator to authorize the department of public health for behavioral health and residential care for treatment services of patients of the department without adhering to competitive solicitation or requirements of the municipal code. >> supervisor chan. >> thank you president politic,

colleagues. this very similar -- >> actually i shouldn't say closure. we previously also waived a procurement contract chapter 21 for the police department and very specifically on automated license plate reader and now we're here waiving another procurement waiver for the department of public health and specifically again it's for the next five years, but for really mental health treatments and beds outside of the city of san francisco which is something that is very specific which i am in support of. the reason being they want to flag is because while i support procurement -- i understand that we have a contract procurement issues meaning we need to continue to work through the

procurement process making sure it's workable. it's effective and i trust that our senior administrator and the controller have been working through this process. with that said i think that at times and that you know we should really focus on very specific problems for waiver -- contract for waiver and in this case again we're drilling down very specific for treatments and services outside of san francisco because we know we want to stay competitive and get services that the city itself cannot offer, but we need and desperately need, and the reason i am also bringing this up is because there is another contract waiver legislation coming through at budget tomorrow. i wanted to flag for you but that one is very different for the department of homelessness and supportive housing. it's sort of this blanket waiver that i am having issue

issue with so with they want on the record i am in support of this and voting for this for a contract procurement waiver because it's very specific, and that is zooming into to a service that we know we need to remain competitive and we cannot be competitive if we stick to our existing procurement requirements. thank you. >> thank you supervisor chan. with no other names on the roster why don't we take item 23, same house, same call. ordinance is passed on first reading and let's go to roll call for introductions. >> supervisor safai is up to introduce new business. >> thank you colleagues. today i am introducing a resolution in support of assemblyman phil ting's bill which he introduced yesterday in the california assembly. ab2359

doubles the number of type 87 liquor licenses, restaurant liquor licenses in particular in the outer mission excelsior and districts in the neighborhood of san francisco that are often harder for restaurant and businesses to start in, and the assemblyman previously introduced this in 2017 and capped it to five per commercial corridor. we're looking to expand that. it's been extremely successful helping businesses particularly up and coming chefs, women, people of color and those without access to capital because the actual license itself rather than being sold for a few hundred thousand dollars the type 87 is particularly chosen for the hard to economically advance neighborhood and it sold for maybe 13,000 or $14,000 so it's

a saithings of hundreds of thousands of dollars but something that is a major benefit. it's helped businesss in my district, the dark horse, the check in, the corner store, the halfway club and now excelsior cover a and cafe whose application is in process. many of the places wouldn't be able to perfect a liquor license in the hundreds of thousands of dollars so we want to see five more businesses in this district and in bayview hunters point and the parts of the city that don't necessarily have access to this type of opportunity. we worked hard during the last seven years to bring significant investments to hard to invest neighborhood and we fought for community ambassador basses all of which had a positive change for the small businesses. another significant improvement has been the establishment of the excelsior community benefit district so

this is about 15 years in the making. we have been doing this work in the community and now through the legislative process, and six years later the vacancy rate is starting to go down. many of the businesses are starting to thrive with this type of opportunity so i want to thank assemblyman ting for thinking of our neighborhoods and other districts in fran and oewd for the investment and partnership and focusing on revitalizing our businesses, and the rest i submitted. thank you. >> thank you supervisor safai. supervisor stefani. >> thank you madam clerk. colleagues as chair of the public safety neighborhood services committee i am calling for regular hearings for the san francisco police department and the g human resources to recruit and retain personnel. president peskin and i were at the safety meeting at the roadwaying club after a horrible incident occurred in the morning as a

swimmer was on the morning swim and beauten up badly and we got questions how many police officers we have and the shortage and who we're doing so this an attempt to have monthly or quarterly whatever we deem appropriate in committee to have hearings where we're at and in terms how many officers we have and what we're doing to recruit them and the update to share them with our constituency. i have always said public safety is a baseline obligation of what a well functioning city government should. do it's in absolute crisis we're 700 positions sworn and civilian officers short what is needed for the demand of service. what i emphasize repeatedly public safety is paramount of the the shortage of police officers excess bates challenges and recovery from the pandemic in numerous ways. while we make the best use of the resources we have the san francisco police department is not a department we

can simply demand doing with less with public safety and i that will as we keep telling the public we need more officers on the streets we need to be explicit and explain what we're doing about it. given the heightened concerns about public safety in the neighborhoods and it's important to have transparency and direct the challenge therefore each month i will ask the police department and the department of human resources to come to committee and report on current staffing level and needs are for personnel. how many vacancy do we have funded and going unfilled and what and why that is? barriers to hiring and bottlenecks with administrative processes with background checks taking too long with department of human resources to get into the academy class and how retirement and sick and leave are affecting staffing because if you look at the number of police officers we have and half that and that's how many patrol officers we have. the number doesn't reflect how

many people are actually out on patrol. the public is rightfully seeking answers for the shortage and it's crucial to understand that we recognize the severity of the crisis. by increasing transparency on this issue we can raise awareness of the urgency to address this crisis and develop meaningful recruitment and retention programs and also i am submitting a request to the budget and legislative analyst office to report on the city and county of san francisco spends money on antihuman trafficking programs and example and compare the funding and trending sourceses of the initiatives of the city and county of san francisco with those of adjacent counties including alameda, contra costa and santa clara and san mateo. in the report on human trafficking and san francisco report the department on the status of women highlighted the significant challenges phased by the city in collecting precise and substantial data primarily due to the covid-19 pandemic.

ensuring availability of accurate data and adequate resources is imperative for making a impact on this issue which is affecting way too many. our goal is leverage the findings from this report to enhance our understanding of the current landscape and refine our approach to antihuman trafficking efforts in the city and county of san francisco. experiences taught us enhanced coordination among city departments community based organization and law enforcement agencies significantly strengthens our ability to address complex issues like human trafficking. this report will serve as a valuable tool in ferring better collaboration and informed decision making as we collectively work eradicating human trafficking from our city. the rest i submit. >> thank you supervisor stefani. >> madam clerk why don't we go to the 230 special order of accommodations. this are three today and i will do them in district order starting with myself and i would like to

use this opportunity to welcome into our chambers a very special guest who sadly never had the chance to come and join the board of supervisors for mayor's question time given that voters didn't approve proposition i after he left city hall in 2004 and i am sure we regrets missing out of this cherished ritual and had to have a better reason for his appearance and what a better opportunity to recognize his induction into the california hall of fame of 2024. i would like to welcome the former mayor of city and county of san francisco willie lois brown junior to the people's chambers. mayor brown please come forward. [applause] >> for those who are

not aware the california hall of fame honors individuals and families who embody california's innovative spirit and have made their mark on history. the hall and its exhibits are housed in the california museum in sacramento. the hall of fame was conceived by then california first lady maria cliveer and opened in 2006 with 13 charter enshinees. i may add that mayor brown advise governor schwarzenegger to never induct a politician for fortunately he ignored his sage advice. in addition to being a resident of california for at least five years inductees must embed the spirit of california and the california dream through work and accomplishments while making a blasting and significant contribution to the state, the nation and the world. all of these accomplishments should serve as an inspiration to others

to further their own dreams. i don't believe it's afternoon over statement to say that willie brown encapsulates these requirements to a t. what is more california dreaming than a young charming ambitious african-american from texas leaving a deep segregated south at age of 17 to move to san francisco where he was thrust into interracial movement and political activism and elected service. not only served in the state and nation in the california national guard but went on to become a california state assemblyman as he likes to remind him or me, the year i was born. and became the legionary speaker of the california state assembly for longer than almost anybody in the history of this state. he will

be forever known in this building as "the mayor" after leading the city and county of san francisco from 1996 to 2004. i know i have alternated my origin story between tree planting and/or mayor brown as to how i got into politics, but sufive to say we drove each other crazy when he was mayor but over time i developed quite the relationship with mayor brown and respect his leadership qualities and his known strategies and ability to negotiate and build community allies, strong relationships that transcend racial and ethnic identities, faith practice and sexual orientations. in fact the ability to recognize leadership qualitys in young leaders lead to alliances that build

the diverse and dynamic democrat party today and joins the los loboses and go, goes in the hall of name and recognize my friend and sometimes adversary and legend and colleague willie lois brown junior mr. mayor the floor is yours. >> which one of these things to i use? >> that one works. >> all right. perfect. perfect. mr. president and your fellow members of your board it ramaytush very well surprise you but this is the very first time and all of my years. >> . >> in the world of

politics that i have ever appeared before the board of supervisors. i mean this is amazing for me. i want you to know that. literally and i suspect that people think it's not true. it is true. i have been in your chambers but i have never appeared before your board to receive any kind of an honor, and literally in my political lifetime i would never expected it to come from aaron peskin. [laughter] >> i mean how could this be? what has occurred in the change in the world i spent a lot of time with age average in the past few years but i am never where i am so honored. i

appreciate your interrupting your normal work time. >> . >> i am here promptly at 230 which i was supposed to be. it's unusual for me for to be on time anywhere, but i looked forward frankly to seeing what were doing when you saw me in your presence, and i am absolutely genuinely honored and delighted. your legislative body is not unlike the legislative bodies that i have been a part of for the longest period of my career. i loved the legislature. i did not ever hold great respect for the

executive branch of government and then term limits came along and outed me from the legislative branch, and then i learned how wonderful and how impactful a legislative branch could be if it worked well with executive branch of government, and being at that time elevated to the executive branch of government. i had at many times in the california legislature i tried to figure out how to abolish local government. i always thought they were unnecessary and then i became the mayor of san francisco, and you and your colleagues literally presented me with the challenges that i had frankly had

experienced. i loved being the mayor of the city. i love it more interacting with the legislative branch of city government. i came to become very respectful of the legislative branches of city government so much so that i have not related back to my place of origin the lettive branch of government at the state level. i have stayed focus on local government, and one of my weekly at almost 90 years of age now one of my weekly activities is that when i get coffee with your president which he pays for the coffee which really pleases me because i don't find many politicians willing to pick up the tab of tab with anyone else and i am

slightly delighted and when he told me he was going to do this i wasn't sure i believed him you about i called him early this morning after preparing and saying prayers last night i got the word to be here at 230, and i am here promptly at 230 so to each and every one of you thank you very, very, very much. thank you. >> mr. speaker if you request join us in the well here we would like to take a picture with you. [applause] >> madam clerk the

show must go on. okay. right. our next special accommodation will be presided over by district 9 supervisor hillary ronen. >> thank you so much and i want to see where is dee. please come forward. hello. colleagues i am absolutely thrilled to honor dee today, a beloved community member and small business owner of -- [inaudible] within the greenway that helped to revitalize the neighborhood. after lived in san francisco for many years dee moved to the neighborhood in 2012 developing quick and deep

connections that have anchored them there ever since. dee say visual artist and coffee consorries and worked in the former barrel cafe before the pandemic before it shut had a good understanding of taking over the business when seeing that the owners wouldn't reopen. seeing a need for community spaces and good coffee they hatched the plan to open the cafe. the concept of hey neighbor came from letter writing and people and open -- [inaudible] curiosity towards ones neighbors and create a space where everyone feels welcome and a haven for neighbors in the depth of the pandemic. this attachment to coffee start said a

child when neighbors prepared it for the neighbor. coffee is a sacred ritual and proud to be part of the neighbor's routine centered around a good cup of coffee. dee is a central part of the greenway and recruiting and certificating volunteers and pop ups to feed people out for garden workdays. dee is always happy to set up tour and delights and native landscapes that has beautified a former blighted alley way and the compost gets its daily boost of grind and enriches the native plants and brought artists to the space with galleries and rise up bakery for delicious breads every morning and local farmers for the

signaturure jams and costee rosters to cell curriculum culture on a rotating schedule to celebrate these masters and thank you for opening the small business during the pandemic. that takes guts and for turning hey neighbor into a center of gravity for the neighborhood but most of all thank you for the commitment to bringing people together and celebrate local unsung talents in the arts food and coffee culture. congratulations dee. [applause] >> thank you so much for this accommodation i really appreciate it. when i first opened hey neighbor coffee i didn't realize how important as a to be so visible and

engaged as a black openly queer individual and how much it means to the community. portola is really near and dear to my heart when i moved out there i instantly found my family, my community and i look forward to showing up to work everyday, and gallivatting and nurturing not a safe space not only for neighbors but for anyone that stumbles upon or finds their way into portola. i am a person of very few words and thank you again. [applause] >> and our next

special order commendation is from our district supervisor shamann walton. >> thank you so much president peskin and congratulations to the other honorees here this afternoon. colleagues today we have the privilege of honoring bayview hunters point native danielle hillman a ballet student at san francisco ballet. [applause] >> nothing exemplifies the importance of black history like highlighting young black leader who is are change hangers in our community. danielle has played many roles at san francisco ballet over the last several years but in 2023 she made history becoming

the first ever black ballet dancer from san francisco to star as clara in the nutcracker. [applause] >> with grace and strength danielle has captivated audiences breaking barrier and inspiring countless dancers. through her commitment to excellence and unwavering determination she not only excelled in her craft but as beacon of representation and empowerment for the black community and young women in the world of classical ballet. she's i distancer, writeer and artist who used createddivity to vibrantly express herself of the at 13 she launched her art business aiming to make black joy common place in bayview hunters point. with light and love

she embraceses the calling to transform the dark corners of the world into bright joyful moments. danielle your journey will continue to inspire generations to come reminding us that dreams know no bounds and the stage is a place for all to be seen and celebrated. i am excited to celebrate you and honor you today in city hall as you claim greatness. proud to be your representative and can't wait to see whew you accomplish next. congratulations. [applause] >> i just like to thank the board of supervisors and district supervisor shamann walton for giving me this award. this means so much to me and being in the spotlight for the first time so grateful for it is experience. it made me feel so special to be chosen out of

the hundreds of girls in the hut cracker and during the audition i had the mind set to aim for another small role, a butterfly and in the end i got that role plus collar a i started ballet at the ymca at six and now a student from san francisco ballet from pretending to be a dancer to be clara in the nutcracker is a dream come through. by the first audition i couldn't shall the steps and the next one i got the solo memorized. later in the rehearsal the instructor told me i was lighting up the room and i was elegant and it's important to go for higher dreams of something you didn't think you could get

achieve. it will help you with anything. if i kept thinking to myself i am small so i'm going to stay small i would have stayed in that little position but when was in a small position in 2022 i didn't think to myself this is insignificant. i was thinking if i could get this part what else could i achieve and how could i level up? it's easy to think your role is unimportant but being in ballet told me you're going to be a side character a couple of times. i have been in several shows and productions and being collarar if the first time and first time being a main character when you work hard and practice and show up you can accomplish great things. i only hope i can aspire more people to keep following their dreams. thank you. [applause] >> madam clerk let's

>> back to our roll call for introductions. >> yes. given that it's supervisor walton's turn we will come back to him and go to supervisor chan. >> thank you madam clerk, colleagues that was interesting. because today i am introducing a resolution to honor san francisco ballet principle dancer tan on the eve of her retirement from the san francisco ballet.

that's interesting one rising star and one -- you know another one that can celebrate her career. she was born in shanghai and started dancing at 10 with their academy. arch fer father hesitated wanting her be a doctor or lawyer finally her parents decided that she could dance after they flipped a coin. in 1992 the san francisco ballet artistic director saw her dancing in paris and invited her to guest at the san francisco ballet. in 1997 she was named the ballet's principle dancer the first chinese dancer and the youngest in san francisco ballet history. she had travel with the san francisco ballet and counts among her best accomplishments dancing with the san francisco ballet in china with the 20th

anniversary with the company and danced with them for 29 seasons and retiring after her last performance tomorrow, february 14, which also happens to be her 48th birthday. i hope you will all join me to wish her much joy and happiness in her second act and the rest i submitted. >> supervisor dorsey. >> thank you. >> supervisor engardio. >> thank you. >> supervisor mandelman. >> i will submit. >> supervisor. >> thank you. >> supervisor peskin. >> submit. >> supervisor preston. >> submit. >> supervisor ronen. >> thank you colleagues i have a couple of items today. first i am introducing a resolution adding commemorative street name of [inaudible] at holly circle. in 2020 an incredible young man named shawn

was shot and murdered by jerad tan from the vallejo police department. he was a san franciscan and born to argentine immigrants and graduating from city college in a major in latino study participant of the youth organizations including several in the city and the excelsior boys and girls club just to name a few. he was a natural born leader who mentored risk in the community. shawn was a bright light and committed to social justice and involved with the justice for marrow wood and others. he encouraged peers to get involved in communities and passionately read literature on social justice with cesar chavez and gloria [inaudible] and malcolm x the leaders he looked to up most. he leaves an

incredible legacy in the community and the board of supervisors unanimously passed a resolution urging the police to release the body cameras footage of the killing and his sisters who are here today and incredible forces of nature held a block party and was attended by hundred and opportunity to remember the life he lead celebrate the impacts he had on the community and demand justice for his death. in 2021 the board also unanimously passed a resolution due clarifying june 2 a day in his honor in the city and county of san francisco. a few months later the community library had the grand opening on holly park circle as a tribute to his legacy and a fixture encouraging young people to read books on this these issues. a mural of his life was

introduced on van ness street in the latino cultural district. the intersection this marks where shawn grew up and he was taken from us far too early but his memory leaves on. this commemorative street naming will remember his legacy and remind the community of his contributions. i want to thank supervisor preston and supervisor walton for the early co-sponserships and of course thank the sisters for tireless work to educateit community about the live of their brother and fight police violence against all community was color. secondly colleagues today i'm introducing legislation with mayor breed that will extend the first year free ordinance they first authored in 2021. as you know this is a program to support

and revive san francisco small businesses especially as we first begin -- excuse me -- especially as we first begin to come out of the pandemic. each of us here day in and day out see how tough it's operate a small business and this lowers the burden and make it easier for small businesses in the city and this waves the cost of first year permits and registration fees. this program enrolled over 6200 small businesses and waived over 2.38 million in fees. this legislation will extend the successful program through june 30, 2025. i want to thank mayor breed, the treasurer and tax collector office and office of small business for the hard work and continue to support the first year free program and the rest i will submit. >> thank you

supervisor ronen. supervisor walton. >> submit. >> thank you. seeing no names on the roster mr. president that includes the introduction of new business. >> colleagues we have two minutes until our 3:00 p.m. special order. too little to start public comment so why don't we sit here for another 80 seconds and then we will go to our 3:00 p.m. special order board of supervisors sitting as a committee of the whole.

clerk would you please read items 21 and 22 together. >> yes. items 21 and 22 pertain to i public hearing of the board of supervisors convening a committee of the whole today, february 13 at 3:00 p.m. pursuant to the california health and safety code as cited and the redevelopment plan section 4.72 for the

tran redevelopment project area and consider ground leases with transbay two senior for 15,000 per year and the ccdc trans bay 2llc for 1 dollar per year. the ground leases each for a term of 75 years for the purpose of developing a mixed-use affordable housing for housing for low and extremely low seniors including formerly homeless seniors and ground floor commercial space at 200 folsom street and make the appropriate findings. >> supervisor dorsey do you have any opening comments? >> i do. thank you supervisor peskin and nice to start a hearing with reflective meditation. that was nice. thanks to the clerk's office for the work to calendar this important and time sensitive item today. transbay block two west will be a nine story 151 unit senior affordable

housing project at folsom street and beale street in the neighborhood i represent. it will be developed and managed by the chinatown development corporation or ccdc with 154 affordable units and one manager's unit. i know this doesn't come to news for the colleagues but i will say it for the public they have a long distinguished partner on affordable housing development in san francisco providing homes to more than 5,000 san franciscans including low income families and adults and seniors who might otherwise afford to be san franciscans. while the portfolio includes a couple developments in the area and on mission bay boulevard we are excited to have that partnership extended mere to another neighborhood we serve. along with residential units this project will include resident

amenities spaits and open space and improvement and bicycle parking and three ground floor community commercial units. funding sources for the $125 million project include $60 million in federal tax credit equity and $65 million gap loan from the office of community development and struck or ocii. this hearing is pursuant to state law as well as the redevelopment plan and together with the accompanying resolution its purpose is for this legislative body to approve ocii to execute the ground leases and two, to make findings that the ground leases include a consideration to be received by ocii that is not less than fair reuse value and assist with the elimination of blight. the bond for this project was approved as item 7. this resolution as cited will be the time board action ahead of the anticipated early march construction start and

so throughsh through the chair i would like to invite jasmine, the ocii development specialists to come up before we vote on the item. >> great. we have the office of community investment infrastructure report. please proceed. >> you can. good afternoon president peskin, supervisors. my name is jasmine. i'm a development specialist at at office of community investment and infrastructure or ocii and i am here to present on item 22 for the affordable housing development located in trans bay known as transbay block two west. as during dog mentioned the purpose of the resolution is authorize the commercial and ground leases for this project and make i finding that the ground leases include a consideration to be received by ocii is not less than fair use value and assist in the elimination of blight. first a brief background on the transbay redevelopment project

area. the flan was approved in 2005 with the intent of creating a new mixed-use mix use neighborhood following the loma presitta earthquake. zone one is administered by ocii and zone two is under the jurisdiction of the planning department and they're obligated to give 45% of affordability in the area. ocii over seen the completion of over 2,000 unit and 700 are affordable units. transbay block two west is one of the are maintaining sites in zone one and critical to meeting the overall area affordability requirements and comprise of two projects two west and two east and both 100% affordable housing with each project individually financed and owned and operated. two west is a project serving senior house holds and

two east will serve families. chinatown development center and [inaudible] were served as developers for them respectively through a dom pettive process. the funding was approved by affordable housing loan community and the west project was awarded bond allocation. last month the commission approved the permanent loan and groupedsh ground leases for two west and last week budget and finance committee approved the resolution and to today's meeting and the board approved item 7 for the bond issuance. next slide. the residential component consist 151 unit was affordable housing for seniors and seniors experiencing homelessness at folsom street and beale street and 150 available to households earning 15 to 50 percent of the

median income and one managers unit and has a commercial component of three units. for financing purposes ocii will enter into two leases for both components. next slide. the plan requires ocii to submit the report and obtain board approval for the transition of the trans bay properties for the health and safety code as cited. as noted in the report the estimated and highest best use value of the residential parcel is approximately 15.$3 million and for the commercial 2.four million. the restricted use is determined by the value of the lease payments during the 75 year ground lease term and the residential parcel is approximately $292,000 and the commercial is $19.48.

and substantially less than the fair market value but this rent is necessary to ensure the successful and continued operation of the affordable housing project and commercial spaces. next. so at this time i can answer any questions supervisors may have and also available for questions from ccdc. we have abigail brown the project manager here and with your approval we will close on financing and begin construction early next month and thank you for your consideration. >> thank you. and jasmine does that conclude your presentation? >> yes it does. >> supervisor dorsey. >> thank you so much. i don't have any questions. i don't know if anybody -- i don't see anyone else on the roster but president peskin if there's no questions i would like to make a motion to file the hearing. >> why don't we take public comment before we file the hearing.

>> okay. >> are there any members of the board who would like to peek? if so you can come up to the microphone. if not i will close public comment. public comment is closed [gavel] and seeing no names on the roster this public hearing has been held and now is filed. colleagues we now have the resolution to approve the ground lease agreement before us for consideration. madam clerk can you please call the roll on item number 22. >> on item 22 supervisor safai, absent. supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor engardio. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin. >> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye. >> supervisor ronen.

>> aye. there are 10 ayes. >> the resolution is adopted. [gavel] >> madam clerk let's go to public comment. >> all right those in the chamber and would like to provide general public comment to the board of supervisors you are able to speak to the mayor's appearance here in this chamber today. can you speak to the minutes as presented. you can speak to the items on for adoption without reservation to items 26 through 29. all other matters on today's agenda are subject to a public hearing and not topics for your discussion, but we would like to hear from the first speaker. we're setting the timer for two minutes. welcome. >> you know me. anyway i would say it's not to say positive from lies on the government. [inaudible]. again i think i need to go back to technology.

this is a part of the problems we're dealing with in the entire world. i'm going to start to introduce from french. [speaking foreign language] . ai -- we said that last time. we know that now. never mind you guys -- not part of the team -- you shy away from it. it's not going to work. you have two weeks until the end of this month only to get san francisco bay area rid of the pictures, the pictures of young children. you have been putting all over the city in the area here. using

technology to make the [inaudible] look ugly. you have until the end of this month. your line of credit for happiness and your reason for being is getting shorter by the day. remember you have to also put at&t in there. you also have to put wanting the use of any cell phone as [inaudible] as others for social behavioral health and health. that is mental health, therefore physical health. it's getting shorter for you to be up here so that's done. -- [inaudible] you have limited time -- >> sir -- thank you. next speaker please. >> i have a hand out.

i'm ready. good afternoon. last week i spoke here and since then i have been asked by multiple people and agencies to provide more detailed information and specific systems used and the document pass out is from the city and county of san francisco enterprise system. you will have the name. system. i'm keeping it unnamed system during my comments due to its dealing with ni -- [inaudible] controlled inform. and cui and hipaa requirements. i need the board of supervisors' immediate attention and action on this item. on saturday i sent more detailed information to the sheriff, chief and assistant chief and director of public health and improper usage of the system. the board of supervisors, mayor's office and the city administrator should

be part of this conversation and part of the solution. this deals with cyber infrastructure, cybersecurity, compliance, protected data management and intellectual property. correcting this and making this the number one priority is vital to the 11 districts in san francisco and needs immediate attention by the board of supervisors. finally i want to apologize to the full board for not getting this inform to you in a timely manner. just be aware there were a lot of people out there trying to prevent you from getting this information when you can make the right decisions working together and i have full confidence in this board of supervisors. thank you. >> thank you for your comments. we welcome the next speaker. >> good afternoon everyone. my name is ashley and the surviving sister of shawn and i am here to express my strong

support for the proposal to honor my brother with the commemorative street naming and his death left an indelible mark in the home and the community and san francisco community and recognizing his way in this way would honor his life and his life was cut short but his memory inspires us to fight for justice and accountability. by doing this in his honor we pay tribute to his life and ensure his story is never forgotten. as the sister of member of this communities i believe it's important to acknowledge and remember the individuals who have made significant contributions to our city even if those contributions were cut short. honoring him with the street naming would be a reminder for the fight of justice and equity inoir. so i urge you to consider this proposal by the seriousness and compassion. by approving this street naming for shawn you can demonstrate

solidity with families and friends and commitment of building a more equitable and just community. thank you for your consideration and input on this important manner. thank you. >> thank you for your comments. >> good afternoon. i am also here in support of the same resolution. my name is michelle and also the surviving sister of my brother and i am here to support the resolution that hillary written on behalf of our brother. our parents immigrated from argentina and living in bernal heights for the past 29 years. we have deep ties in the community and our neighborhood. shawn -- my sister and i -- we all attended the elementary school on park street. upon his death we also created knowledge of library in his memory which is at at introduction of park street and holly circle. the impact

his life and legacy left on the family and community has been deeply impactful and the many time weiss were invited to speak on a national scale we give the deep ties to the city of san francisco. we hope this gesture will ribel impact at large and give families and communities hope and ways to honor the lives of loved ones.ip believe that he is the beakon of hope to the family and community and a tragic death but i believe working in partnership with the board of supervisors and local agencies together we can embody what partnership and hope continues to look like in our community so thank you and i urge you for strong support. thank you. >> thank you for your comments. welcome to the next speaker. >> good afternoon board of supervisors. i am also here in support of the commemorative street naming for

shawn. this has significance for the community but also for the memory of a remarkable individual they had the immense pleasure and honor of knowing and i mentored him. shawn was more than a story that you know and story behind the untimely loss and transcends values and place. his legacy was one of courage and unwavering solidity and perseverance. his message is a testament to justice and unity. he stood tall for the city and in the face of adversity was steadfast in the police peles and speaking truth to power. the betterment should not go oven noticed and a true city baby and warriors and giants fan and girl and boys club and san franciscan in every sense of the

word and this would -- constant reminder of the values he championed solidit and knowledge of self and perseverance. as the city is our responsibility to honor those that dedicated themselves to making our community a better place. naming the corner in place of him is what the city can do for the legacy and the message resonates for generations to come. i urge your support. thank you. >> thank you for your comments. welcome to the next speaker. >> thank you. good afternoon honorable members of the board and san franciscans. i'm a proud daughter of the city and born and raised here like shawn and like me loved the city so deeply and the impact and legacy is felt in the community and to this day. you can feel the presence at at library at holly park and all siblings attended that elementary school

and his family immigrated to almost 30 years ago. this resonates with me and san franciscans that saw ourselves reflected in his background and struggle of resistance and struggle and perseverance and encans lated by employs him and the person motto, push, pull and strive. i urge the board of supervisors to support the renaming of this street. [speaking spanish] . >> thank you. >> good afternoon. i support the renaming for shawn monrosa. that was a really tough loss and a tough loss for the 49ers but it's important that the house the homeless and -- [inaudible] public safety and team equity winning the big game for the city. go cal care and living wage for the service workers especially those that worked during the

game and beyond. i'm proud of my supervisor for the support and [inaudible] make racist comments about commissioner konstins commissioner konstin. >> . >> you need to call for the firing and it's not okay and perpetuates injustice and hard to be -- pro-choice. she would run as a trump -- pro-life trump republican if it was convenient and a republican vote bush senior over dukakis at that time and the supervisor engaged with other supervisors and maybe i wouldn't be angry towards this and put a boot on our neck. it's getting fascism and ole carky. i want to people are not impressed with the

profanity. this isn't some 80's sweater com and drinks milking. i have free speech rights and there is no one to -- magicking to stop cussing. i am out of her. >> civility starts with me. thank you. next speaker please. >> it's a privilege to be able to speak today. my name is marko. it's difficult for me to digest the fact that shawn was taken, not only from his community but from his family. situations like this are why our elders are always worried for the youth and why we're educated to act and do certain things to avoid

situations like these. when it when it shouldn't be something we're introduced to but something prevented from the start. i'm glad to see this family fight the fight that shouldn't had to be fought and why we need to push for change and recognition for those taken from our communities and other families. because of damage and pain size a hole too big for anyone to fill so thank you san francisco for stepping up and showing us that you care. >> thank you for your comments. next speaker please. welcome. >> good afternoon everybody. i unfortunately didn't have the opportunity to meet shawn. that was also taken from me. i come down here from sanitation -- sacramento and it was important to make the drive. we would have definitely been friends. i'm a

little too young to say he could have been my son and let's go with the reality of all of these issues. he could have one of your sons. there's a select few people that could bore him as a son but the reality when individuals like this grow up in the margins sometimes their stories or they themselves are able to make it to the center and wake up a city, a state and nation. sometimes they're one dot from a helicopter camera and the people reminding us of our morality or awakening us to a new reality and this gives shawn something and his family something he was denied of and over time he would have been a teacher to everybody. we know he was a teacher to his family and to his community but he would have been a teacher to everybody

so this commemorative sign gives him the opportunity to be locked up by that person what is this sign for? who is shawn >> to remind them of freedom fighters and that want peace and justice and many from san francisco and commemorating him is another person from the city recognized as such and i thank everybody who is in support allowing him to be a teacher again. it means a lot to me personally. >> welcome. >> good afternoon supervisors. my name is can i havein ortiz and the copresident of the san francisco latinx democratic club and support the street naming in honor of shawn and thank you for bringing this forward. his life was taken unjustly and his family and loved ones deserve justice and search for the

justice for his murder. this naming will be the reminder that shawn was and the hope he continues to inspire. i want to rewind to a moment of summer of 2020. george floyd, shawn montrose a we saw mass mobilizations and protests. and calls for change for police accountability for calls for change on what the definition of what true public safety is. folks talked with me and said it was the 1964 moment so i want us to think now we're at in 2024. we're making strides backwards. there are folks in here pushing regressive measures and give aways to the police and lessen accountabilities for years to k as you support the naming of the street i want to ask yourself supervisors what are you doing to inch what the system so there is not another shawn? thank you for your time. >> . >> thank you for your comments. welcome to the next speaker.

>> hi guys. thank you for letting me speak today. what a great opportunity to be in the audience today. you get two mayors. that's pretty awesome i must say. i was very, very lucky, glad i made the choice to come. mayor willie brown is someone i look up to and admire and respect a lot. the same with mayor london breed. i was actually in my apartment watching mayor brown's inauguration when elected mayor and happened on the other side on polk or as they call it and a gotten era in san francisco and i count myself lucky here today to see the commenteddation awarded so what i want to touch base with you on

is just the state of the situation, the state of the case, just the situation. i hope it gets better for the city. i really do because the city is in a hard spot. it's in a very difficult spot and it's trying its best to pull through to make it to get on the other side. there's a lot of things pulling it back, a lot of things pulling it back and it's just a bummer. it's a shame. it's a shame what is going, but i think we can pull through. i think we have brighter days ahead. i think there's a beacon at the end of the tunnel. i see the beacon, see the light. i think it's this week, this friday. i think that's the day the city is going to see something great happen to someone. it's going to see something great happen and nobody could take that away. nobody could steal it. nobody can get in the way of that so i am telling you right now you better be

listening. thank you very much and honor and respect to those -- [off mic]. >> thank you for your comments. are there any other members of the public to address for public. mr. president. >> public comment is closed. [gavel] >> could you read the reference rapid. >> items 26 and 29 were introduced without reservation and a nap mouse vote is required for first reading and alternatively a member can request it go to committee. >> seeing no names on the roster madam clerk would you please -- oh i'm sorry, supervisor melgar. >> sorry. i wanted to be added to number 26 please. >> the record will reflect that supervisor melgar has cosponsoring ared item 26 -- >> you're currently on there. >> yeah, you are.

>> [off mic]. >> 27. >> i'm sorry. >> noted sorry about that. >> okay. and supervisor stefani is the sponsor of 27. supervisor safai. >> please add me as a sponsor to item 27 as well. >> co-sponser to item 27. supervisor walton. >> thank you president president. i thought i was also sponsor -- co-sponser of 27. please add me. >> noted. seeing no other names on roster on the adoption without committee reference a roll call please. >> on items 26, 27, 28 and 29. supervisor safai. >> aye. >> supervisor stefani. >> aye. >> supervisor walton. >> aye. >> supervisor chan. >> aye. >> supervisor dorsey. >> aye. >> supervisor engardio. >> aye. >> supervisor mandelman. >> aye. >> supervisor melgar. >> aye. >> supervisor peskin.

>> aye. >> supervisor preston. >> aye >> and supervisor ronen. >> aye. >> . there are 11 ayes. >> those resolutions are adopted and motions approved. madam clerk will you please read the in memoriamed >> meeting is adjournod the beloved individual for supervisor peskin for as cited. >> we are adjourned. [gavel] >> . story.

>> hi he my name is dean pes continue district 5 supervise and congratulate it sfgovtv on their thirty year anniversary thank you, so much for bringing transparency and accountability to government and for all you do happy anniversary. >> on behalf of all we want to say thank you, sfgovtv thank you for being here. and your help in the women's leadership convention and congratulations sfgovtv on our thirty years of service the office of government affairs he happy to partner

>> come shop dine and play. taraval street is open for business. >> my name is mark recollect the owner of lou's cafe on taraval street. since 2010, my brother and tj and vince and mom [indiscernible] we used to sandwiches all the time. we said why not us. geary boulevard in 2010. i figured i might to start in another location and when i opened the location in 2015. we treat each customer as family and we make our food with love and make sure everyone is happy. i recommend everyone come out to the sunset. >> take time for teraival bingo, supporting small business, anyone can participate. it is easy, collect stickers on a bingo style game board and enter for a chance to win awesome prizes. for

[music] >> office of initiative start in the 2017 and started as a result of community advocacy. our transgender nonbinary community advocates were really letting our government know that we needed to be heard. we needed to be considered and policy and budget decision and so, then the mayor lee and founding director of spark created officeof initiative that allow us to advocate for equity for transgender and nonbinary communitiful we focus on 4 areas. training, education for the city employees. we focus on civic and community engagement making sure our leaders have a voice and are heard by our elected officials. we work on policies and programs

to make sure our city is responsive to transand nonbinary community and add voice to departments to integrate transinclusion in policies, procedures and practice. >> we still have, lot of work to do to improve and address equity in san fran for our community upon i feel that we are on the right track and seeing how people's lives are improving thanks to those changes. i do think it is unique that our local government is sponsive to transgender communities so i hope that people can remember that despite the work we had, we seat progress. we seat change and there is hope for transpeople in san francisco and wherever we come together and organize to improve our lives. [music]

>> good morning, every one. hello. thank you so much for coming to today's press conference mayor, conference and our lunar year the year of the dragon. san francisco has a special place in history, in december of 1992, san francisco watched the city where the historic unveiling of the first-ever lunar new year took place in this entire country. and since 11992, we have many national first days and national ceremonies. but whether we get the first day or