oblast, so that ukraine refuses to support russian volunteers and stops these operations, that is, the actions are absolutely terrorist, there are military operations going on, and the russians, as usual, are just hitting the civilian population, so that, as terrorists, they will create conditions when the government of ukraine will have to decide on the command the armed forces and the top military-political leadership will have to decide how to get out of this situation, when the russians just really start their sabotage. groups are clearly aimed simply against the civilian population, they do not have them there no military goals, they just go in , kill civilians, it’s been several months, and before that it was when they just sent, you can see that special forces forces are just sitting there, who have some plan to enter the territory of ukraine, roughly speaking, to carry out terrorist activities there acts and go back, they have such and such a task, just to terrorize civilians in... in principle, they do this with

all ukrainians, now they have concentrated on sumy, on sumy oblast. after winning the elections, or pseudo-elections, putin said that we do not rule out that a so-called sanitary zone may emerge between ukraine and russia, a sanitary zone that will allow us to avoid shelling from the ukrainian side and various types of weapons, as far as possible. it is likely that an unsanitary, i would say a gray zone will arise between ukraine and russia, in the donetsk and luhansk regions, it exists, but it turned the cities located in this zone into ashes, they destroyed the cities and village, and whether it can in some way secure russia, if in we will have long-range missiles, well, for example, taurus or... stormshadov, which will fly

to the territory of the russian federation? well, of course not, it's just really delusional, because when we talk about strikes on the wengelsii airfield, or strikes 1000 km from the ukrainian border on oil refineries, or on military facilities, well, what a gray zone, what is he talking about mean? he means that the ukrainian artillery should not shell, not shell russian military objects on the territory of russia, but... in order to do so, even artillery strikes were not enough, and even the aviation is not enough, it is necessary for the russians to enter the ukrainian territory, in fact to establish a sanitary zone there, as he says, or to push the ukrainian troops out of there, this is unrealistic, just the opposite is happening right now due to the arrival of russian volunteers and the establishment of their own gray zones or zones effective control that they are trying to establish in the cities

occupied by the putin regime in russia itself, that is, putin simply does not control the situation, or is trying to mislead his population that now they will create some sanitary zone and after that, it will stop, for example, the unstable situation, let's call it that, in the belgorod region, well, it won't happen like that, more and more, we just said that ukraine will continue to increase production. drones, ukraine will increase its capabilities both from the point of view of aviation and from the point of view of artillery, because more ammunition will be supplied to us, that is , russia will have to answer for its actions, no sanitary zones putin will be able to stop it, and until then , until they withdraw their troops, more and more the war will move to the territory of russia.

well, there is one more prediction about the future of the russian-ukrainian war: the chairman of the armed forces committee of the united states senate , democrat jack reid, believes that the adoption by congress of additional aid to ukraine will help the ukrainian army to slowly push back the russians throughout 2024, although i will not allow it to happen the picture breakthrough next year 25 should be a new offensive operation that will hopefully allow them to establish a fire. control over crimea, this will significantly complicate the situation the russians and, hopefully, will force them to sit down at the negotiating table. mr. mykhailo, here is what jack creed says, and about fire control over crimea, does this mean that we will have more attack aircraft, and which fly at a greater distance than now? well, from a military-strategic point of view, i cannot agree with the senator, because if they give us... these

weapons, for example, several hundred atakams, 300 km, why wait until the 25th year, that is, i believe that from from a geopolitical point of view, if we postpone the o... if, of course, we will have the same tools and the same aviation, the same long-range attacks, then i think that we should carry out these decisive actions to establish fire control over crimea in the 24th year. i am not talking about the fact that we will be able to conduct offensive operations in donbas, but to conduct limited offensive actions and to conduct really decisive actions in the direction of crimea, if we have the appropriate ones. moments, and the senator is talking about this very thing, i think that the 24th year has not yet passed, and the 24th, well , of course, if the help of the united states will come to us in december of the 24th year, then , of course, there will be little chance for us to really take

any decisive actions in the direction of crimea, if they do at least make a decision and help in april, and i am not talking about money, i i'm talking about real help. already in the form of atakams and new patriot systems and more ammunition and long-range for highmars, the same glsdb, if all this is carried out, therefore, in principle, we will have certain windows of opportunity open in the summer and autumn, let's hope that it will be so . thank you, mr. mykhailo, for this conversation mykhailo samuts was a military expert. friends, we work live on the espresso tv channel, as well as on our youtube and facebook platforms. for those watching now. us live on youtube and on social networks , please vote in our poll, we ask you if there is a parliamentary crisis in ukraine, yes no, if you are sitting in front of the tv, pick up your smartphone or phone and vote if do you think that there is a parliamentary crisis in ukraine, 0800-211381, no, 0800-211-382, all calls to

these numbers are free, at the end of the program we will sum up the results of this vote, we will be in touch later... hrybachuk, head of the center for joint actions, former vice-prime minister for european integration, former head of yushchenko's presidential office. mr. oleg, i congratulate you, thank you for being with us today. congratulations, there is a crisis, it can be seen with the naked eye. ah, well, how is this crisis visible to the naked eye and how to get out of this crisis? it is necessary to change the system of government organization, because... when there is only one small branch of government in ukraine, which i am too led in his time, replaces both the government and the parliament, then you will never achieve the effectiveness of the other branches, that is , we have a chronic problem, banking street,

the structure that is there, which is not elected by anyone, chronically dominates other branches of government , and now at such a moment it is very felt, well... we will watch how they will benefit from this parliamentary crisis, because it is clear that there is no majority, and it is necessary to reformat the majority, accordingly reformat the government, and accordingly the central authorities and distribute this political responsibility among other forces, let's talk about what happened in russia, because immediately after the so-called elections, putin came to the fsb and began to talk about the fact that the special service... is the key guarantor of the security and sovereignty of russia, while he admitted that it is the russian rebels who are now howling against the putin regime in the border regions of russia. let's listen to what putin said. the challenges we face, attempts to undermine our development,

require us to be systematic and consistent work in all directions, in the economy, technology, culture, social sphere, in strengthening our state and social institutions. when i spoke about these traitors, i ask, as has always been the case in our history, not to forget who they are, to identify them by name, by name, we will punish them without a deadline. mr. oleg, this means that putin, relying on these drawn 87%, is now returning to the times of stalin and saying: "well

, we will suppress all of you now." well, since he made the first fsb visit when the election results were already announced, it is possible. short a trip to the past, my first visits to the kremlin there, to get to know my colleague dmitry medvedev at the time, who headed putin's administration, i had there. strange things, when i arrived in the hall of delegations , some people met me there, they had such badges on their lapels from a car, i was sure that it was a car, and that it was the service of the president of russia , or something, that it was sent by medvedev, it turned out , that it was a car and employees who met me, this is the so-called union of fsb veterans, and they drove right into the kremlin there... they took me to the most holy place, and then there was a meeting with this and that union, with

veterans of the fsb, and there i heard a lot, first of all, i did not understand why i was invited there, but since it was from medvedev, i i understand that part of their program, they said something like this, that the biggest holiday in russia, so that i understand, it was a general, the head of this veteran service, they are all wearing these badges, they are so little... well, quite typical that the biggest holiday in russia is december 20, the day of the chekist, and this is what volodymyr volodymyrovych celebrates, and everyone admitted knows that this is the biggest holiday for putin, for all of russia, for the entire establishment. second, 75% of all key positions in russia at that time were staff members of the kgb, fsb, and they controlled all key positions. financial flows, for example , with each oligarch there was a general who

was conditionally a financial manager there, god knows how it is with every large structure, with foreign russian banks, and one more thing that i later heard more than once, for these brothers it is very important to earn money, they simply talked more than once about the need to earn, to earn... and the last thing that really surprised me was that they were so confident, i don't know who they think we ukrainians are, but they perceived me as a very close person to putin, to yushchenko, they knew this and wanted to immediately awaken relations, and they said that they started a dialogue with my predecessor in order to create the most modern analytical center in the whole world. just on the territory of the secretariat there the president, they will do, they will bring

their computers, their equipment, and we will have the most modern analytics in real time , the kind that no other structure in ukraine has, and i, i missed it so casually, but the most interesting thing is that then this general, he flew in his plane, and he was sure that i would meet with him, and he was still waiting, there was an adviser to the president of ukraine, well, of course i refused the meeting , but what is quite serious is, well, this people, well, not boys, honored officers, why them they were so sure that it is easy to deal with us, that you can simply invite the kgb, fsb to the president of ukraine, and they should provide us with all the understanding of the world through the analytical center, that is, that this is a country... kgb, fsb , i have no doubt, and since then, it has only intensified,

so when putin talked about where, when he first went to this particular service, including, i think, he also spoke with veterans there, then i i am not surprised by this, this is a country of kegists, fessists, so when i hear the topic from good russian women, beautiful russia future, then it only causes a crooked smile, because the russia of the present and the future is in the hands of this power. these people, in the meantime, putin still wants some negotiations with ukraine, regarding the future of ukraine, of course, on his own terms, and this , by the way, is evidenced by another fact that xijin pin, gathered with macron, there is an official excuse of 60 years there diplomatic relations between china and france, but, as politiko writes, the main topic of their meeting. and this is precisely russia's participation in the peace talks on ukraine, kyiv rejects such participation

at the first, or at least stage, the establishing stage, when the summit will take place according to zelensky's peace formula, what does dmytro kuleba say about the role of china, about their role in ending the war? he literally says this, it's obvious to me that china definitely has a lot of potential. in order to put an end to this war of russian aggression against ukraine because of the special relationship that he has with russia, as far as the relationship between ukraine and china is concerned, they have never... experienced problems either in the main issues or in bilateral relations, the trust between exists, the minister also emphasized that kyiv and beijing continue dialogue regarding zelenskyi's peace formula. mr. oleg, can china influence putin and the end of russia's war against ukraine, given that putin

has now gained or drawn this huge number of russians' support, and in him. a second breath literally opened, so he is ready now, referring to this, to this support, to the fact that more than 80% of the russians there voted for him, and accordingly for the war, and further push his weapons and troops to the west. well, i would would like to simply disagree with our chief diplomat, because in fact we have. there have never been warm relations with china, the leadership of the chinese communist party in our country perceived all our orange revolutions and revolutions of dignity very coldly, well, there president yushchenko did not manage to make a single visit to china there, he was the only ukrainian

president who made a triumphant trip there for 3-4 days, president yanukovych was there, and president yanukovych had just... really such a warm, rather dangerous relationship for us, because dubious agreements were signed there agreements worth many billions, so i understand that our diplomat says this, because diplomats are supposed to say such things, but china does not accept ukraine even now, especially against the background of the fact that ukraine is now in the camp of democratic countries, that we have our own mromstay that we are a sign that we are moving towards the european union and nato, for china. politically it is absolutely it is a threat to china and russia and it is important for china that russia does not lose and china will pursue a pragmatic policy, he, he actually acts as a lawyer for russia, and these the visits of chinese representatives did not bring anything new for ukraine, and

there are many points in china's rhetoric that, as a matter of fact, the kremlin voices, and in particular this is not... dignity, necessarily the participation of russia, orban also talks about this, another big friend of ukraine and the european union and nato, about the fact that without russia, erdoğan is repeating this thesis that it is impossible to conduct negotiations without russia, in principle, after the elections, the situation is very strange, today i saw scholz's speech before the members of the bundestag. and he said there, president putin, and... we heard yesterday the statement that officially the spokesman of the ministry of foreign affairs of germany said that russia considers these elections to be falsified, and putin will not be called the president, but will simply say vladimir putin, that is, this means that china sees russia as a tool

to achieve its own interests, and the interests of russia and china. coincide with the change in the world order, the abolition of unipolarity there , as they say to the world, the reduction of the maximum influence of the united states and the actual redistribution of spheres of influence, which they almost openly talk about, and it has nothing to do with there is no peace here, and the ukrainian position is clear, so russia should be informed and invited to negotiations. after the entire democratic world agrees on its positions, this is, conditionally speaking, the second round after switzerland, the second round of negotiations, or the second round of this implementation of the peace formula, and the fact that china wants to put itself there, and that china makes it a condition that russia will be at the first meeting, well , it makes an impossible position for ukraine and for

those members of the western alliance who, in principle , perfectly understand what is happening. in which there are no illusions about the position of china either, you mentioned the united states of america, the former president of the united states of america, donald trump, and the person who claims to become the leader of this country for the second time, softened the rhetoric regarding the withdrawal of the united states of america from nato, if he is taken as president, of course , he has now said that the states will remain 100% in the alliance if europe fulfills its financial obligations. let's hear what trump said. the united states should pay its fair share, not its fair share all the others, it is fair, i believe that the conjunctions. states paid for 90% of nato, maybe all 100, it was not fair, and if they play fair, america will be with them, yes 100%, 100%. mr. oleg, there is a difference between

trump pre-election, and trump election and trump elected, that is, as much as what he is saying now, as much as can be expected after his probable victory, you know, even... there, the american american congress at one time limited the possibilities or then-president trump's authority to there are international obligations, in particular , such as withdrawing from nato or some other important for the united states for national security agreements, so this is the reaction of trump, trump, he he he, when he works for his audience, he uses certain phrases, but he very often contradicts himself. to himself, those people who know him well claim that , in fact

, it is impossible to predict trump's behavior, it is impossible to like him, it is very difficult to try to somehow establish some kind of personal relationship with him, but one must understand that he is a populist, and populists are always have a very fine sense of the moment and that trump after the announcement of the withdrawal... of the united states and what he will give there, what he will agree to, or tell putin that if those countries that do not pay contributions, remember, he said that if they say russia will attack them, then they say yes and yes, they should, this caused a colossal storm of protests among trump's closest allies, and of course he changed his rhetoric a little, but it is very important that we do not catch some pleasant or logical news for us and... to the fact that trump - he is a politician that ukraine can count on, ukraine cannot count on , because it is not predictable, and the main thing is that the leaders of the european union

understood this perfectly, so the choice is american, with the americans, but the world, the european world in particular, clearly understood , that we need to minimize dependence on who will be the next president of the united states and pay significantly more for independents. for the security of europe, you know, if now there are two 2% was considered the maximum there at the beginning there 10 years ago only three countries paid, now there are 17 countries, in my opinion, have adopted this barrier of 2%, so now it is already about 3%, and some countries have increased their contributions to defense and security even more, and europeans have taken the issue of their own security very seriously , realizing that this war is actually taking place on the european continent. and this is their continent, and this is their home, and trouble is knocking at the door of their home. thank you, mr. olezh, for the conversation, it was oleg hrybachuk, former head of yushchenko's presidential office

and former vice-prime minister of ukraine. during this broadcast, friends, we are conducting survey, we ask you about whether there is a parliamentary crisis in ukraine, yes, no, if you watch us on tv, you can continue to vote, well, here are the interim results of the survey, 93% say yes, 7%. no, we will continue this survey in the second part of our program, there are discounts on vitamin d3, d3 max, 10% in pharmacies, psyllium, ban and oschadno, there are discounts on mikrolax, 20% in psyllium, pam and oschadno pharmacies. riv is a leading manufacturer of windowsills and materials for windows. riv, for more than 20 years, we have been creating quality for... affordable at a price there are discounts on pektel plyushch, 10% in psarynyk, bam and oskad pharmacies. there are discounts on zipelor of 10% in psyllanyk, pam and oskad pharmacies.

exclusively on the air of our channel. congratulations, friends, politklub is on the air on the espresso tv channel. the most relevant topics of the week: russia's war against ukraine, the war in the middle east, the crisis on the border between ukraine and poland. topics causing resonance in our society: drone attack on kyiv and other cities of ukraine, drone attacks on moscow and other cities of russia. analysis of processes, that change the country and each of us. the country must get the right to start. negotiations on accession to the eu. vitaly portnikov and guests of the project: we are bored, because there is nothing to fight about, let's invent, they help to understand the present and predict

the future. for the world. a second trump presidency will be terrible. a project for those who care and think. political club. every sunday at 20:10 at espresso. the premium sponsor of the national team represents. united by football. together with... exclusively on the air of our channel. congratulations, friends, politklub is on the air on the espresso tv channel. the most relevant topics of the week. russia's war against ukraine, the war in the middle east, the crisis on the border between ukraine and poland. topics that resonate in our society. drone attack on kyiv and other cities of ukraine, drone attack on

moscow. and other cities of russia, analysis of processes that change the country and each of us. ukraine should get the right to start negotiations on joining the eu. vitaliy portnikov and guests of the project: we are bored, because there is nothing to fight about, let's invent, they help to understand the present and predict future. for the world, a second trump presidency will be terrifying. a project for those who care and think. political club. every sunday at 20:10 at espresso. the football format changes the broadcast time, from now on you can immerse yourself in the atmosphere of football every monday at 22:00, professional analysis of matches, exclusive interviews, goals, goals, emotions, a project for both experienced fans and just people who appreciate unbiased view of football, football format every monday at 22:00 on

espresso tv channel. hello, this is svoboda ranok, an informational project of the radio svoboda, top guests every day, this is the shipping district, kherson, live connection, we are somewhere in the vicinity of bakhmut, we tell the main thing, on weekdays at 9:00. congratulations, friends, the second part of the verdict program is live on the espresso tv channel. today we are talking about this. putin's fifth presidential term, challenges for ukraine and the world, under what conditions is it possible for russia to return in between'.

people's legal field: to accumulate weapons and ammunition. duda calls to prepare for the invasion of russia so that it does not happen. when putin will be ready to attack nato. crisis of power in ukraine. servants of the people spoke about the benefits of dictatorship. can the reformatting of the monomajority solve the problems of the parliament. friends, we are working live on the tv channel. as well as on our youtube and facebook platforms, for those who are watching us on social media right now, on social media platforms, follow us on our social media, we're everywhere, and also, during today's broadcast, we 're doing a survey, we you we ask about this, is there a parliamentary crisis in ukraine, yes no, if you watch us on youtube, everything is fine simply choose either yes or no, the button , write your comment, if you have your personal opinion, if you watch us on

tv, take your smartphone or phone and vote, if you think there is a parliamentary crisis in ukraine 0800 211 381 no 0800 211 382, ​​all calls to these numbers are free, call, at the end of the program we will sum up the results of this vote. today we have as guests political scientists maksym rozumny, doctor of political sciences, mr. maksym, i congratulate you, good evening, thank you for being with us today, oleg sahakyan, head of the platform. the only coordination center, mr. oleg, i welcome you, thank you for joining our broadcast. my greetings are the same. vitaly kulyk, director of the center for researching civil society problems. mr. vitaly, i congratulate you and thank you for joining the broadcast. i congratulate you. well, gentlemen, since we are asking our viewers whether they think there is a parliamentary crisis in ukraine, i will ask you too. sorry, everything is obvious.